Best Colby Cheese In April 2024

Here, we’ll review the top 10 Best Colby Cheese on the market today. We’ll provide an overview of the pros and cons of each product. Read on for our selection of Best Colby Cheese.

To help you in your search, we have completed this list of the Best Colby Cheese.

Top Rated Best Colby Cheese Of 2024

Rank	Product Name	Score
1	Colby Cheese Longhorn 48oz Half Loaf Buy Now	9.7 Buy Now
2	Nibber Jack Crate by Wisconsin Cheese Mart Buy Now	9.5 Buy Now
3	3 Lb. Longhorn Colby Cheese - Wisconsin Cheeseman Buy Now	9.1 Buy Now
4	Tillamook Medium, Sharp, Swiss & Colby Jack Sliced Cheese Sampler Buy Now	8.8 Buy Now
5	Shullsburg Creamery - Colby Jack Cheese - 5 Pound Loaf Buy Now	8.6 Buy Now
6	igourmet Authentic Wisconsin Colby by Widmers Cheese Cellars (7.5 ounce) Buy Now	8.3 Buy Now
7	WISCONSIN CHEESE COMPANY'S \| 1oz. Colby Jack Cheese \| Snack Stick \| 24-1oz Buy Now	8.1 Buy Now
8	Wisconsin Deluxe Colby Longhorn Cheese, Sausage & Cracker Gift Buy Now	7.8 Buy Now
9	Sesmark Sesame Thins, Colby Cheddar Cheese, 7 Ounce (Pack of 12) Buy Now	7.5 Buy Now
10	Tillamook Cheese 2lb Baby Loaf (Choose Flavor Below) (Colby Jack) Buy Now	7.2 Buy Now

1. Colby Cheese Longhorn 48oz Half Loaf

Buy Now

9.7/10 our score

Buy Now

Longhorn is a style of american colby cheese defined by its round, long, orange cylindrical shape.
A wisconsin original cheese! the first colby was made in 1874 in colby, wisconsin.

2. Nibber Jack Crate by Wisconsin Cheese Mart

Buy Now

9.5/10 our score

Buy Now

One of our customers favorite gift assortments
Sharp cheddar, monterey jack with wild morel and leek, seasonal monterey jack, edam, colby
In a wisconsin made branded wooden box
A great variety of cheeses to nibble on or put on your favorite sandwich
All wisconsin products

3. 3 Lb. Longhorn Colby Cheese - Wisconsin Cheeseman

Buy Now

9.1/10 our score

Buy Now

4. Tillamook Medium, Sharp, Swiss & Colby Jack Sliced Cheese Sampler

Buy Now

8.8/10 our score

Buy Now

5. Shullsburg Creamery - Colby Jack Cheese - 5 Pound Loaf

Buy Now

8.6/10 our score

Buy Now

Natural colby and monterey cheeses
Economical 5 pound loaf
Perfect on sandwiches
Serve sliced, diced or shredded
Order more than one item from any of the shullsburg creamery product lines and save on shipping (see shipping rates and policies)

6. igourmet Authentic Wisconsin Colby by Widmers Cheese Cellars (7.5 ounce)

Buy Now

8.3/10 our score

Buy Now

Ships expedited in an insulated package to ensure freshness
Widmer's is one of the few remaining companies to make authentic colby
Similar in flavor to cheddar, colby is softer and has a more open texture and higher moisture content

7. WISCONSIN CHEESE COMPANY'S | 1oz. Colby Jack Cheese | Snack Stick | 24-1oz

Buy Now

8.1/10 our score

Buy Now

Wisconsin cheese company's 1oz. cheese snack sticks. these great colby jack cheddar cheese sticks are individually wrapped in a peel pack. colby jack cheddar cheese is our blended colby and monterey jack plus cheddar cheeses into one stick. bold in flavor and a great snack. refrigeration required.

8. Wisconsin Deluxe Colby Longhorn Cheese, Sausage & Cracker Gift

Buy Now

7.8/10 our score

Buy Now

Included: deluxe colby longhorn cheese, sausage & cracker gift, (2) long horn cheese, smoked summer sausage, water crackers **if products become unavailable an equal product will be substituted.
Easy to send delivered from your online order by amazon |fast and easy delivery to your home or sent as a gift | some of our items are eligible for free shipping with amazon prime
Ready to serve all of our value gourmet cheese and sausage selections are ready to serve and this item does require refrigeration | each unique gift is hand packed with quality and care | made in the usa
Nationally known wisconsins best & wisconsin cheese company, 100% wisconsin cheese! wisconsin deluxe colby longhorn cheese, sausage & cracker gift
Gift ideas perfect for every holiday, christmas, corporate gift basket or personal event, birthday, thank you or appreciation, get well, graduation, anniversary, congratulations, friendship, summer, new home and for gift giving holidays, christmas, thanksgiving, easter, mothers day, fathers day, memorial day, veterans day, labor day, 4th of july and others, gift for...