Best Home Toasters In May 2024

Check out our product review of the Best Home Toasters. We tried 10 models and can tell you the absolute best varieties.

To help you in your search, we have completed this list of the Best Home Toasters.

Top Rated Best Home Toasters Of 2024

Rank	Product Name	Score
1	Disney DCM-21 Mickey Mouse 2 Slice Toaster, Red/Black, 1 Buy Now	9.7 Buy Now
2	Nostalgia HDT600RETRORED Pop-Up 2 Hot Dog and Bun Toaster With Mini Tongs Works Buy Now	9.5 Buy Now
3	Nostalgia HDT600COKE Coca-Cola Pop-Up 2 Hot Dog and Bun Toaster, With Mini Tongs Buy Now	9.1 Buy Now
4	Toaster 2 Slice,Extra Wide Slot Toaster,Stainless Steel Retro Toaster with Bagel,Cancel,Defrost,Reheat Function,Bread Toaster,Bagels Buy Now	8.8 Buy Now
5	Nostalgia TCS2AQ Grilled Cheese Easy-Clean Toaster Baskets and Adjustable Toasting Dial, Aqua Buy Now	8.6 Buy Now
6	The Brave Little Toaster by Walt Disney Home Entertainment by Jerry Rees Buy Now	8.3 Buy Now
7	Nostalgia RTOS200AQ New and Improved Retro Wide 2-Slice Toaster Perfect For Bread, English Buy Now	8.1 Buy Now
8	Kitchen + Home Toaster Oven Liner - Heavy Duty 100% PFOA & BPA Buy Now	7.8 Buy Now
9	Simple Home Inspirations Cotton Toaster Cover - Cafe (2 Slice 12 x 8) Buy Now	7.5 Buy Now
10	Oster 2097682 2 Slice Toaster Metropolitan Collection with Rose Gold Accents Buy Now	7.2 Buy Now

1. Disney DCM-21 Mickey Mouse 2 Slice Toaster, Red/Black, 1

Buy Now

9.7/10 our score

Buy Now

Non-skid rubber feet
Hinged crumb tray
Adjustable browning control
Mickey character imprint on toast
Extra wide slots with self centering bread guides and high rise toast lift

2. Nostalgia HDT600RETRORED Pop-Up 2 Hot Dog and Bun Toaster With Mini Tongs Works

Buy Now

9.5/10 our score

Buy Now

Great tasting hot dogs: toasts upto 2 delicious, regular-size or extra-plump hot dogs and two buns at the same time. cord length: 34 inches
Drip tray: slide out the drip tray when done toasting for easy cleaning
Adjustable settings: adjustable toasting timer and stop toasting button allows you to toast your hot dogs to your preferred doneness
Works with other dogs: also works with pre-cooked chicken dogs, turkey dogs, veggie dogs, sausages and brats
Hot dog cage & tongs: keep hands safe when removing hot dogs by using the included hot dog cage and mini tongs
Cord wrap: wrap the appliance cord underneath the base of the unit for tidy storage

3. Nostalgia HDT600COKE Coca-Cola Pop-Up 2 Hot Dog and Bun Toaster, With Mini Tongs

Buy Now

9.1/10 our score

Buy Now

Works with other dogs: also works with pre-cooked chicken dogs, turkey dogs, veggie dogs, sausages and brats!
Cord wrap: wrap the appliance cord underneath the base of the unit for tidy storage
Adjustable settings: adjustable toasting timer and stop toasting button allows you to toast your hot dogs to your preferred doneness
Drip tray: slide out the drip tray when done toasting for easy cleaning
Hot dog cage & tongs: keep hands safe when removing hot dogs by using the included hot dog cage and mini tongs
Great tasting hot dogs: toasts up to 2 delicious, regular-size or extra-plump hot dogs and two buns at the same time. cord length : 34 inches

4. Toaster 2 Slice,Extra Wide Slot Toaster,Stainless Steel Retro Toaster with

Toaster 2 Slice,Extra Wide Slot Toaster,Stainless Steel Retro Toaster with Bagel,Cancel,Defrost,Reheat Function,Bread Toaster,Bagels

Buy Now

8.8/10 our score

Buy Now

Storage with removable tray : bread crumbs are collected in a removable tray at the bottom of the toaster, so just pull it out and clean the crumbs immediately.
Grillabovethetoasteryoucanuseittowarmacroissantoreverythingyouwanttoeatwith when toasting bread.useyourimagination!
Meet various needs4 basic functions:bagel/cancel/defrost/reheat function and 7 level adjustable brown settings from light to dark, meet everyone's taste.
1.5" extra wide slots :5.4" x 1.5" wide slots toaster with self-adjusting guides, wide enough for thick bread, meet all your daily toast needs.
Convenient to useeasy to use and gets hot fast for time saving. just place the bread in the toaster, set the browning control to the desired setting, press toasters lift lever down, toast will automatically pops up.

5. Nostalgia TCS2AQ Grilled Cheese Easy-Clean Toaster Baskets and Adjustable Toasting Dial, Aqua

Buy Now

8.6/10 our score

Buy Now

Adjustable toasting dial - select your preferred doneness on the toasting dial and create your perfect melted grilled cheese sandwich.
Removable toasting baskets - two reusable toasting baskets conveniently hold your cheese sandwich in place while toasting.
Cool-touch - the housing and handles stay cool to the touch for keeping hands safe.
2 slot toaster - make 2 thick-stuffed grilled cheese sandwiches in just minutes!
Simple controls - equipped with cancel, preheat, and defrost functions.
Cord wrap - storage is made easy and tidy with a cord wrap located in the bottom of the unit.

6. The Brave Little Toaster by Walt Disney Home Entertainment by Jerry Rees

Buy Now

8.3/10 our score

Buy Now

7. Nostalgia RTOS200AQ New and Improved Retro Wide 2-Slice Toaster Perfect For Bread, English

Buy Now

8.1/10 our score

Buy Now

Lighted controls: lighted control buttons feature bagel, defrost, and cancel options
Cord storage: cord storage in bottom of unit allows for tidy storage
Extra-wide toaster: the 2 large slots are perfect for toasting bagel halves and thick slices of bread, english muffins, and more
Perfectly toasted: the 5 browning levels allow you to choose your preferred doneness
Easy clean up: crumb tray easily slides out so you can keep your toaster clean

8. Kitchen + Home Toaster Oven Liner - Heavy Duty 100% PFOA & BPA

Buy Now

7.8/10 our score

Buy Now

Extra heavy duty our toaster oven liner is the thickest and sturdiest on the market. the unique patented coating outlasts traditional liners and can handle temperatures up to 500f.
Keep oven clean - our reusable non-stick toaster oven liner catches drips, spills and debris to eliminate stuck on mess in your oven and wipes clean effortlessly, so you dont waste unnecessary time and effort cleaning.
Versatile designed for toaster ovens, but can be used as a baking mat or pan liner. microwave and dishwasher safe.
Fda approved dont settle for thin oven liners made of inferior materials that curl, crack, smoke or releases chemicals. our toaster oven liners are 100% pfoa & bpa free.
Trim to fit measuring at 11x13inches, this toaster oven mat fits most standard toaster ovens, but can be cut to fit any size.

9. Simple Home Inspirations Cotton Toaster Cover - Cafe (2 Slice 12 x 8)

Buy Now

7.5/10 our score

Buy Now

Dont hesitate to send us your toaster dimensions to get the best fit!
For best results, machine wash cold on gentle cycle. hang or lay flat to dry, machine dry not recommended.
There are standard variations for both 2 slice and 4 slice
Made in the usa

10. Oster 2097682 2 Slice Toaster Metropolitan Collection with Rose Gold Accents

Buy Now

7.2/10 our score

Buy Now

Bread toaster features a toast lift that elevates food for checking on browning throughout the toasting cycle, and allows for easy food retrieval when toasting is complete
Defrost option takes bread from frozen to toast in one simple step, cancel button stops the toasting cycle at any time
Bagel option automatically adjusts the toasting time for bagel thickness
Oster toaster offers 9 unique shade settings that let you make toast just the way you like it, from light to dark and crispy
This oster 2-slice toaster from the stylish metropolitan collection will enhance any kitchen dcor with its elegant rose gold accents